The Appeals Council is the part of Social Security that reviews a judge’s decision when you lose your disability hearing. You ask for review in writing within 60 days of receiving the hearing decision. The Appeals Council can deny your request, send the case back to a judge for a new hearing, or decide the case itself. It doesn’t hold a new hearing, and it only changes a decision when the judge made a legal or factual error or when important new evidence comes in, so a strong request points to specific mistakes in the decision.
Key points
- You have 60 days from receiving the judge’s decision to ask the Appeals Council for review (20 CFR 404.968).
- The Appeals Council looks for errors in the hearing decision. It doesn’t rehear your case.
- Most often it either denies review or sends the case back to a judge for another hearing.
- If you won part of your case, an appeal can put the part you won at risk, so get advice before filing.
- While your appeal is pending, you generally can’t file a new claim for the same benefit.
Wondering what your claim could be worth? Try our free SSDI benefits calculator.
What is the Social Security Appeals Council?
The Social Security Appeals Council is the final level of appeal inside Social Security. It sits above the administrative law judges who hold disability hearings, and its job is to review hearing decisions for errors (20 CFR 404.967). It’s a national body based in Falls Church, Virginia, so your case is reviewed there, not at your local hearing office in Boston, Springfield or Lawrence.
The Appeals Council is the fourth step in the disability appeals process. It comes after the initial application, reconsideration and the hearing. If the Appeals Council denies review, the judge’s decision becomes Social Security’s final decision.
How do you request Appeals Council review?
You request Appeals Council review by filing a written request, usually Form HA-520, within 60 days of receiving the hearing decision. Social Security assumes you received the decision five days after the date printed on it, unless you can show it arrived later (20 CFR 404.901). You can file online, by mail or at a Social Security office.
- Meet the deadline. If you miss it, you need to show good cause for filing late, such as a serious illness or not getting the notice (20 CFR 404.968(b) and 404.911).
- Ask for the hearing file. Your representative should get the exhibit file and the hearing recording to find where the decision went wrong.
- Send a written argument. You can submit a brief explaining the errors, and the Appeals Council considers it (20 CFR 404.975).
Our appeal deadline calculator works out your 60-day deadline from the date on your notice.
What does the Appeals Council look for?
The Appeals Council grants review only when the hearing decision has a specific problem it recognizes (20 CFR 404.970). Disagreeing with the outcome isn’t enough. It reviews a case when:
- The judge abused their discretion, such as refusing to let you present important evidence.
- The decision contains an error of law, such as applying the wrong rule or skipping a required step.
- The judge’s findings aren’t supported by substantial evidence in the record.
- The case raises a broad policy or procedural issue that affects the public interest.
- You submit new evidence that relates to the period before the hearing decision and has a reasonable chance of changing the outcome, and you have a good reason for not submitting it earlier.
Common errors include not explaining why a treating doctor’s opinion was rejected, ignoring evidence that supports your limits, and relying on vocational expert testimony that conflicts with the job information Social Security uses. Our guide to the vocational expert explains how that testimony works.

What can the Appeals Council decide?
The Appeals Council can deny review, dismiss your request, send your case back to a judge, or issue a new decision itself (20 CFR 404.967, 404.977 and 404.979).
| Outcome | What it means for you |
|---|---|
| Denial of review | The judge’s decision stands and becomes final. Your next option is federal court. |
| Dismissal | The request is thrown out without a review, often because it was filed late without good cause. |
| Remand | The case goes back to a judge, often the same one, with instructions to fix specific problems. You usually get a new hearing. |
| New decision | The Appeals Council decides the case itself. This is less common, and the decision can be favorable or unfavorable. |
A remand isn’t a win, but it gives you another hearing with the error corrected and a chance to add evidence.
Can appealing a partially favorable decision backfire?
Yes. If the judge approved part of your claim, such as benefits starting from a later date than you asked for, an appeal lets the Appeals Council review the whole decision, including the part you won. It can send the entire case back for a new hearing, and the next decision could be worse.
That doesn’t mean you should never appeal a partially favorable decision. It means you should compare what you’d gain, usually extra months of back pay, with what you could lose before filing. Our guide to what happens after your hearing explains the different kinds of decisions.
Lost your disability hearing?
Talk to a disability attorney now. Free consultation. No fees unless you win.
Call (617) 683-1983How long does an Appeals Council review take?
An Appeals Council review usually takes many months, and it often takes a year or longer. There’s no deadline for the Appeals Council to act. You can check the status by calling the Appeals Council or through your representative.
Keep seeing your doctors while you wait. If the case is sent back for a new hearing, the judge will want current records, and any gap in treatment can be held against you.
Should you appeal or file a new disability claim?
You generally can’t do both at once. Under Social Security’s current policy, you can’t file a new claim for the same benefit while your request for Appeals Council review is pending (SSR 11-1p). You can file a new claim for a different benefit, such as SSI while appealing an SSDI denial.
Whether to appeal or start over depends on your case:
- An appeal may make sense when the decision has a clear legal error, or when a new claim would lose months or years of back pay.
- A new claim may make sense when your condition has gotten worse since the hearing, when you’ve reached an age that makes the rules more favorable, such as 50 or 55, or when your date last insured isn’t a problem for a later start date.
This choice affects how much back pay you could receive, so it’s worth talking through with a lawyer before you decide.
What happens if the Appeals Council denies your case?
If the Appeals Council denies review, you can file a lawsuit in federal district court within 60 days of receiving the denial notice (20 CFR 404.981). A federal judge reviews the record for legal error and doesn’t hold a new disability hearing. Your other option is to file a new application with Social Security.
How Melanson Law Group helps with Appeals Council requests
When a client loses at a hearing, we review the decision, the exhibit file and the hearing recording for errors the Appeals Council recognizes. We tell the client plainly whether an appeal or a new claim is the better path, and if it’s an appeal, we file the request on time with a written argument tied to the record. Learn more about our SSDI appeals representation.
Jack Melanson decided more than 6,000 disability claims over 17 years as a Social Security judge, and he knows how hearing decisions are written and where they tend to go wrong. That experience shapes how we review every decision.
There is no fee unless you win. The fee is 25% of your back pay, capped at $9,200. If we win with little or no back pay, we don’t seek any further payment, and clients are not charged for case costs. See how our fees work.
Frequently asked questions
How long do I have to appeal to the Appeals Council?
You have 60 days from the date you receive the judge’s decision. Social Security assumes you received it five days after the date on the notice, so in practice you have about 65 days from that date.
Does the Appeals Council hold a hearing?
No. The Appeals Council reviews the written record, the hearing recording and any brief you submit. If it finds a problem, it usually sends the case back to a judge for a new hearing.
Can I submit new evidence to the Appeals Council?
Yes, but only if it relates to the period before the hearing decision, has a reasonable chance of changing the outcome, and you have a good reason for not submitting it earlier.
Can I get benefits while my Appeals Council review is pending?
Not for the denied claim. You can apply for a different benefit, such as SSI, if you qualify, but you generally can’t file a new claim for the same benefit until the review is finished.
Can the Appeals Council review my case on its own?
Yes. The Appeals Council can decide on its own to review a hearing decision within 60 days of the decision, even if no one appealed it (20 CFR 404.969). This is uncommon, but it can happen to favorable decisions.
If you lost your disability hearing or received a partially favorable decision, call (617) 683-1983 or schedule a free consultation.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

